5 Steps in Forensic Identification of Paint Source

The standard analytical procedure used for identification of the source of a paint sample has five major steps:

  1. Microscopic examination
  2. Infrared Microscopy
  3. Primer color coding
  4. Paint database query (PDQ)
  5. Topcoat color coding

1. Microscopic Examination of Paint Sample

  • Initial Examination: A stereo microscope is used to assess the number, order, color, thickness, and texture of each paint layer.
  • Diagonal Cut: Using a scalpel, make a diagonal cut along the edge of the paint chip to reveal the layers.
  • Edge or Cross-Section Viewing: The chip can be viewed along its edge or as thin cross-sections under polarized light for further clarity.
  • Features: Any unique or accidental features, such as overspray, irregularities, or characteristics within or between layers, are noted.
  • Layer Sampling: As layers are sampled from the horizontal chip, they are cut or scraped away to reveal the layers below.
  • Infrared Analysis: Samples for IR should be obtained mid-layer to minimize the chance of contamination and weathering effects or reduce the chance of contributions from substrate materials or adjoining layers, especially in “wet-on-wet” applications.

2. Infrared Analysis

Instrumental analysis is conducted on each topcoat and primer layer of paint. For this, FTIR (Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy) is the primary method due to its sensitivity, speed, and discriminating ability.

For analysis, data is collected as transmission spectra with:

  • 4 cm-1 resolution and
  • spectral range of 4000 to 250 cm-1

Caesium Iodide (CsI) optical material is ideal for infrared spectroscopy as it can be used to determine both organic and inorganic components in paint simultaneously.

  • Equipment selection (FTIR models): Digilab FTS-40/60, Digilab 40A, and Digilab 575 all are found by Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) laboratories that can be suited best with high-pressure diamond cell or mini cell and a Harrick 6X beam condenser.
  • Interpretation of IR: Generate key components by their characteristic ‘fingerprint‘ patterns and identify diagnostic peaks by referencing spectra in the Atlas.

For automotive paint analysis:

  • IR data is combined with color and layer sequence data
  • A database called ‘Paint Data Query‘ (PDQ) is used in RCMP laboratories

Step 3: Color Coding With PDQ Database

  • Primer Layer Color is assigned using the hue, value, and chroma designations from the Munsell Book of Color (1976).
  • Topcoat Color is assigned based on a list of standard colors within the database.
  • The presence or absence of any metallic flakes and mica particles should be recorded too.
  • Using this prevents any chance of missing “hits” if an exact topcoat color is not present in the database.

Step 4: PDQ Database Search

  • Paint Data Query (PDQ) database is searched using color and chemical information from the paint layer system.
  • Spectral Comparison: Unknown spectra are compared to hard-copy spectra of each hit to ensure component similarity and relative amounts.
  • Spectral Search Challenges:
    • Large number of similar spectra in automotive paint libraries.
    • Insensitivity of search algorithms to subtle features like shoulders, shapes, patterns, and minor peaks.

Step 5: Topcoat Color Confirmation

  • Topcoat Color Verification: The final step is to confirm that the identified topcoat color matches the colors used by the potential manufacturer for the specified make and model year.
  • Reference Sources: Topcoat color collections, such as the US National Bureau of Standards, topcoat color standards, and trade refinish books (e.g., Dupont), are used for comparison.
  • The list of potential “hits” can be narrowed by eliminating manufacturers and years where the specific topcoat color was not used.
  • Repaint Topcoats: If only a repaint topcoat is found at a scene, only the vehicle’s color can be provided to the investigator.

Reference:

  • The Forensic Examination of Paints and Pigments By David A. Crown [Book]
  • Forensic Examination and Analysis of Paints By H. K. Raaschou Nielsen
  • Forensic Science Handbook By Adam B. Hall, Richard Saferstein
  • The Application of a Standard Color Coding System to Paint in Forensic Science By C. Fouweather, RW. May, J. Porter
  • Forensic Paint Analysis and Comparison Guidelines [Link]
  • Forensic examination of car paints [Researchgate]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *